One family, three futures
Lilly (44) and William (42) Harper own 4 rental properties, in Melbourne, Brisbane, Manchester and Dubai, and want A$150k a year of passive income.
A worked example: one illustrative household, Base scenario, assumptions dated July 2026.
The household
- Lilly 44 and William 42, living in Australia.
- 4 rental properties in 3 countries: Melbourne, Brisbane, Manchester and Dubai. 1 already sold, in Hobart.
- Shares in 2 currencies.
- 2 retirement funds, locked until 2042 and 2044.
- Combined debt A$1.3M.
- Target: A$150k a year of passive income, adjusted for inflation.
Keep all 4 properties
No sales, no purchases.
Income after tax stays under the goal line until 2049, the year Lilly stops work.
Goal year 2049: the baseline. Owned by 2052: $7.1M, adjusted for inflation, the baseline.
Sell Melbourne in 2044
75% of each year's spare cashflow goes to the loans. 2044: the Melbourne apartment is sold, and that money goes to the loans too.
In 2044, A$59k a year comes from the 3 remaining properties and A$95k from a 4% draw on the cash left over. Fewer properties keep growing.
Goal year 2044: 5 years earlier than keeping everything. Owned by 2052: $6.9M, adjusted for inflation, A$151k less than keeping everything.
Sell Melbourne and Brisbane, buy off the plan in Dubai
2027: a second Dubai apartment, AED1.2M: 50% borrowed against the Dubai apartment in the build, 50% a mortgage at handover (2029), costs from cash.
2042: Melbourne and Brisbane are sold. Of the plans that borrow the instalments, this scores highest under their goal, reached in 2042.
Goal year 2042: 2 years earlier than selling 1 alone. Owned by 2052: $6.9M, adjusted for inflation, A$144k less than keeping everything.
Keeping everything reaches the goal in 2049, selling 1 in 2044, and selling 2 then buying off the plan in 2042.
The decision
The Melbourne apartment carries their largest loan. Whether to sell it, and what else to sell, is not a question on its own. It depends on what the household is optimising for, and the search runs every path against each of these:
- Reach the passive income goal soonestThe first year income after tax covers the target, and keeps covering it.
- Reach the net worth target firstGrowing the balance sheet before converting it into income.
- The most cashflow while net worth still growsIncome that rises with inflation year after year, not a one off spike.
- The largest legacy for the childrenWhat is left at the end of the plan, after every tax and every cost.
Value growth 5.5% and rent growth 4.0% in Melbourne and Brisbane; Manchester 2.9% and 3.0% and Dubai 5.0% and 2.0%, their own countries' figures; loan rate 6.24%, inflation 2.5%, drawdown rule 4%, as at July 2026.
Passive income after tax against the target, the Combined Assets rule, retirement funds counted from their access year.
A worked example on one illustrative household. An illustration, not advice; a licensed professional is the person to decide with.
See households like this one